The "Middle East 2020" project defines what a peaceful and
prosperous Middle East will look like in 2020 and discusses how
such a vision can be made real. Launched by TIESWeb (the
Transatlantic Information Exchange System) in April 2004 at the 2nd
Miami Transatlantic Citizens Week, it aims at shaping alternative
visions for a peaceful Middle East, starting from a resolution of
the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and emphasizing the power of
civil society in influencing political and social processes.
The Young Israeli Forum for Cooperation (YIFC), the Israeli partner
for this project, is a non-profit organization cultivating a
generation of young leaders who seek to take an active role in
shaping Israel's future. YIFC's primary goal is to empower young
professionals (aged up to 35) to generate movement towards the
resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and to foster
Israeli-European relations.
YIFC's European partners in this project are dialogue lab, an
organization contributing to the advancement of just and peaceful
societies, and AEGEE (Association des Etats Généraux des
Etudiants de l'Europe), a student organization; and its Palestinian
partner is Palestinian Vision, an organization promoting active
leadership roles for Palestinian youth within their communities
through training and voluntarism. Since 2003, YIFC has conducted a
series of four exchanges among European, Israeli and Palestinian
students and young professionals entitled "The European Role in the
Israeli-Palestinian Conflict". These conferences sought to
strengthen the role of the younger generation in bringing about a
resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and to establish a
new regional network of committed young leaders who would actively
promote it.
Each conference brought together 35-40 participants, representing
different professional, social and political backgrounds, for a
week-long vision-led exchange dealing with the conflict's core
issues. The groups were characterized by ideological diversity,
which ensured the representation of sectors which rarely
participate in people-to-people projects. The aim was to reach new
multipliers and to refrain from convincing the
already-convinced.
Thirty-three vision themes came out of these conferences, which
represent the aspirations for the future of the 150 Israelis,
Palestinians and Europeans who took part in them.
Four themes emerged as appearing in each and every
conference:
1) Mobility/freedom of movement;
2) Respect of human rights;
3) Personal security; and
4) Mutual respect, dignity and understanding.
Four different themes appeared in three of the four joint visions
devised in our conferences:
1) Jerusalem as a shared, undivided capital;
2) Regional cooperation, including other Middle Eastern countries
and the EU;
3) Educational and cultural exchanges; and
4) High standards of living and economic development.
In December 2005, Franck Biancheri, the president of Newropeans,
the trans-European political movement, visited Israel and the
Palestinian National Authority (PNA). The visit was organized by
the YIFC, in conjunction with the (Palestinian) International Peace
and Cooperation Center (IPCC). It included meetings with some 150
Israelis and Palestinians in a series of events and debates which
focused on the hopes, aspirations, fears and concerns of Israeli
and Palestinian students and young professionals, and on developing
concrete initiatives to promote a peaceful future. In a session
conducted in conjunction with the Jerusalem International YMCA,
participants were asked to imagine themselves in the reality of the
year 2020. Each was asked to point out key components of the
reality which he/she would most want to see in 2020, and which
he/she would be most afraid of having to confront.
1) Mobility - Almost all participants identified mobility as a key
factor. The young Israelis and Palestinians saw their ultimate
future as one that included many more possibilities to move around
- whether as a means to enhance personal relationships, to travel,
to gain professional and academic skills or to become part of a
more global system. They expressed their desire for free movement
within their immediate surroundings, to be able to visit friends
who reside on the "other side" and to easily visit neighboring
countries. Mobility was portrayed as the main benefit from a future
peace - it was perceived as a greater value than the vague concept
of peace.
2) Regionality - The discussion concerning mobility aspirations
raised the question: "Mobility where?" Participants wanted open
borders between two independent states - Israel and Palestine. They
also supported a wider regional framework for their countries -
namely the European Union and the Middle East. It was agreed that
Israel and Palestine may have different needs in this regard, i.e.,
Israel has stronger relations with the EU, and Palestine has
stronger ties with the Arab Middle East. The Euro-Mediterranean
regional framework was highlighted as a powerful instrument,
combining both tendencies and allowing interaction within a wider
regional perspective.
3) Leadership - Participants envisioned a civil leadership which is
less derived from the security apparatuses, which attracts
qualified people from various fields of expertise, which is not
corrupt and which acts to transform the societies into much more
open-minded, normalized and equal ones.
During January 2007, the YIFC with its Palestinian and European
partners will hold in Berlin the fifth conference on "The European
Role in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict." The participants will
analyze the core issues of the conflict and build structures for
future constructive joint projects. The conference proceedings will
be published, and a follow-up seminar will endeavor to put into
action the strategic plan devised at the conference.
Conclusions
During the vast majority of our activities, all partners found it
very hard, if not impossible, to dream, to go beyond current
reality towards envisioning in detail an alternative reality. It
seems that it was much easier to identify vision themes than to
create a vision narrative. The tragedy is that both Israelis and
Palestinians are unaware of their shared needs and aspirations, and
doubt whether these even exist. Identifying a common idea is a
first step in formulating a dream.
Participants mentioned the end of occupation and the two-state
solution with a shared Jerusalem as a desired political solution -
but rather than focusing on these elements, they found much
importance in creating an attractive agenda for the post-conflict
era. This seemed to be a useful mechanism to find common ground
between the sides and to attract young professionals to take joint
action. It was mentioned by some as more important than trying to
agree on the details and content of the future peace agreement.
Peace was described as a means to achieve a desired reality and not
as a goal in itself.
The different vision themes that emerged deal extensively with
basic human needs and less with political interests. Issues are
more related to self-esteem, personal and collective feelings and
interpersonal relations. An emphasis was put on the needed changes
within each society. In the long term it takes the form of a
different style of leadership that represents the outcome of a
change in conduct, and that can further promote this process into a
significant and comprehensive social change.
There is a vital need to enable much larger numbers of Israeli and
Palestinian young professionals to engage in conferences and
matching projects such as those organized by YIFC in recent years.
Then Israelis and Palestinians may find it easier to understand
that they do share common hopes and dreams, for which they should
work together.
But we need to keep in mind that the vision emerging from such
Israeli-Palestinian endeavors should be translated into concrete
and pragmatic action plans that will promote it. The promotion of
the vision shall not be left in the hands of the current
leadership, but shaped by the future leadership - the young
professionals of today. Thus, YIFC is working to establish
sustainable Israeli-Palestinian young professionals' alliances,
which aim at identifying the jointly desired futures; understanding
the social process that may lead to the implementation of these
futures; and mapping the different social factors that may
influence this process, for better or for worse. It is further
engaged in endeavoring to include vast parts of the societies in
such a process and developing the relevant action plans.